Rajeev Masand – movies that matter : from bollywood, hollywood and everywhere else

July 8, 2011

No crowning glory

Filed under: Their Films — Rajeev @ 10:00 pm

July 08, 2011

Cast: Tom Hanks, Julia Roberts, Gugu Mbatha-Raw, Cedric the Entertainer, Taraji P Henson

Director: Tom Hanks

Tom Hanks has pretty much made a career out of playing Average Joes, but even the most ordinary characters need interesting stories to merit a movie based on their lives. Larry Crowne, which Hanks co-wrote and directed in addition to acting in it, casts him as possibly the most boring, bland character he’s played on screen yet.

We realize less than five minutes into the movie that Hanks’ middle-aged character, Larry is basically a nice guy. For a sales clerk at a supermarket, whose job involves retrieving abandoned shopping carts from the parking lot and stocking supplies on high shelves, he’s unusually cheerful and has an infectious enthusiasm that he seems to pass on to his colleagues. But then he’s abruptly fired one day when management decides his lack of a college education has made him unpromotable.

Larry quickly signs up for community college, where he makes friends with a fellow economics student who gives him a slick makeover and also introduces him to her boyfriend’s motor-scooter gang, with whom he rides around the city and hits local diners every afternoon. He also gradually softens his cynical and unhappily married public-speaking professor Mercedes (played by Julia Roberts), who will predictably go on to become his love interest in the story. At the end of the film, Larry has got a job in the kitchen of a diner owned by his friend. He’s cleared economics, and he’s also got an A+ in public speaking…although it’s unclear if he got that grade for the charming but vacuous speech he delivered in class, or because the teacher is crushing on him.

Larry’s is not an extraordinary story. Hell, it’s not even that uncommon. So many older Americans go back to college to improve their lives. What makes Larry a somewhat interesting character is the fact that he’s a good man who draws mostly good people around him. But in the absence of a dramatic story around such a character, I’m still not convinced he makes for a compelling protagonist of a movie.

Mike Leigh’s unforgettable film Happy-Go-Lucky was pegged on a heroine who was irrepressibly cheerful, but Leigh invested much by way of character depth to hold up his slim plot. In contrast, Larry Crowne offers neither a memorable story nor a deliciously layered lead.

I never thought I’d say this about a Tom Hanks film, but watching Larry Crowne is less fun than watching paint dry. It’s a huge disappointment from Hanks, who previously directed the thoroughly enjoyable musical comedy That Thing You Do! Even Julia Roberts appears bored out of her skull going through the motions of this film.

I’m going with one-and-a-half out of five for Tom Hanks’ Larry Crowne. My advice to fans of the two-time Oscar-winning star: skip this one if you don’t want your heart broken.

(This review first aired on CNN-IBN)


  1. I follow rajiv like bible and his review has never left me disappointed so i’m not watching this one but i’m surprised he hasn’t reviewed murder2 vat cud possibly be the reason, flick not showing in mumbai,highly unlikely,rajiv in jeddah highly unlikely,rajiv in tripoli not that unlikely he’s a juorno so that can happen but i doubt that cuz he is a movie surgeon so why god knows or rajiv himself straightaway after reviewing hanks and julia flick he began intervieing znmd team.he could have reviewed magnum opus of this week though.

    Comment by shobhit — July 8, 2011 @ 10:51 pm

  2. I liked Larry Crowne. I saw it yesterday, then I searched to see if anyone else saw the Happy Go Lucky relevance–only you! Good catch. I tried posting at the IBN site, seems not to work. Came to check your reviews. I like them, at least those for “Their Movies.” You and I agree Happy Go Lucky is unforgettable. I saw it about a month ago, and I was surprised at that large section of British comments I found thereafter that loathed Poppy and thereby the film. However, all of us foreigners like you and I seem to have consistently positive feelings of their British film and Poppy. “Metal Asylum” – very funny.

    Comment by JDM/USA — July 11, 2011 @ 4:44 am

  3. Tom+Julia and 1.5 🙁 they are my all time favourites…anyways…Hi Rajiv, This website make the things a lot easier :). Can you post review of Shagird???

    Comment by Rajiv — July 12, 2011 @ 6:43 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress